Jay D’amico sound has evolved over the years, honed in performances with his own trio and a variety of other musicians, most notably bassist and lifelong friend Milt “the Judge” Hinton, whom the pianist credits as one of the primary influences on his career. Hinton joined his protégé on Jay’s recording debut in 1982, Envisage, which also featured Bob Rosengarden. Another musician whose influence Jay cites as key is Mike Longo, established pianist/composer and musical director for many of Dizzy Gillespie’s bands. Longo’s CAP Records has released all five of Jay’s CD recordings, which include: Envisage; From the Top; Ponte Novello; Tuscan Prelude; Nocturne; and Tango Caliente. Jay has also appeared on Hinton’s The Judge’s Decision (1985) as pianist and composer.

Jay has also performed with Ben Brown, Marc Johnson, and Ronnie Zito. From 1984 through September 10, 2001, Jay performed as the Pianist in Residence at New York’s Windows on the World and at the Plaza Hotel from 2002 to 2004.